Mystery Inc

Shane L. Waters, Joshua Waters, Kim Morrow

Unlock the unknown with the gang on the Mystery Inc Podcast—your go-to source for real-life mysteries that defy explanation. Hop into our Mystery Machine Tesla as we hit the road, diving deep into the enigmas that leave even the skeptics questioning reality. From haunted hideaways to unsolved crimes, each episode is a riveting journey through the baffling and the bizarre.

The mystery is out there; are you in?

read less

Our Editor's Take

People love mystery stories because of their exciting plots and suspenseful surprises. The Mystery Inc podcast by brothers Shane L. Waters and Joshua Walters continues this tradition. The podcast explores the intriguing world of unsolved mysteries and crimes. It's an audio treat for fans of true crime. They approach stories with a Scooby Doo-like curiosity. The show started in 2022. It has a mix of true crime, historic, and supernatural mysteries.

Mystery Inc offers a stimulating view of the unexplainable. The brothers use their talents to highlight baffling mysteries on the show. These include everything from unsolved killings to chilling disappearances. What happened in the Roanoke Colony? Is Casey Anthony really guilty? Did the Isle of Cannibals really exist? This show has some thoughts.

The hosts also talk about alleged encounters with aliens and legendary stories. Their prior experience in hosting podcasts helps them create an appealing show. Shane's Foul Play: Crime Series and Joshua's Rotten to the Core listeners may like this podcast as well.

Shane and Joshua's camaraderie is contagious throughout Mystery Inc. They deliver intense stories, which sets the tone for the show. They make each mystery understandable and fun. Yet, they don't downplay the seriousness of the crimes. Their wit and high energy make every episode an immersive experience for listeners. Kim, the podcast's producer, sometimes joins the brothers for the Mystery Inc episodes. Kim's inclusion adds an extra layer to the podcast, making it more interesting.

Shane and Joshua both bring their personality to Mystery Inc. The duo captures both intense mystery fans and casual listeners with their engaging tales. They enrich each episode with their vibrant storytelling and inquisitive approach. Together, they journey into the cryptic world of crime and mystery in a way that is light, funny, and shocking. The show provides an enticing inquiry into strange mysteries, keeping listeners entertained.

read less
ComedyComedy

Episodes

50: Blast from the Past: The 1920 Wall Street Bombing
Yesterday
50: Blast from the Past: The 1920 Wall Street Bombing
In this gripping episode, we delve into the chaos and mystery of the Wall Street Bombing of 1920. On the sunny afternoon of September 16, 1920, a horse-drawn wagon packed with 100 pounds of dynamite and 500 pounds of heavy sash weights exploded in the financial heart of New York City, just outside the J.P. Morgan bank at 23 Wall Street. The blast claimed 38 lives and injured hundreds more, leaving a scene of devastation and sparking a frenzy of fear that gripped the nation. As smoke cleared, the question of who was behind this horrific act haunted the streets of Manhattan.Diving into the details, we explore the immediate aftermath of the explosion, the historical context of labor unrest and political radicalism, and the flurry of investigations that followed. Initial suspicions pointed towards anarchists or communists, reflecting the Red Scare that was sweeping through America at the time. Yet, despite the best efforts of law enforcement, including the legendary J. Edgar Hoover, the case remained shrouded in mystery, with no one ever officially charged for the attack. In this episode, we piece together the evidence and testimonies, exploring various theories that have emerged over the decades. Tune in as we attempt to unravel a century-old puzzle, shedding light on a moment that shaped the security measures of the financial district and left an indelible mark on American history.Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
48: The Eerie Encounter in Exeter
Apr 16 2024
48: The Eerie Encounter in Exeter
Zoinks! Gather 'round, gang, for a spooky tale from the small, quiet town of Kensington, New Hampshire. It's the wee hours of September 3, 1965, and young Norman Muscarello is hitchhiking home to Exeter after a date. Suddenly, he spots something that makes his hair stand on end—flashing bright red lights in the sky, but these ain't no ordinary emergency lights. This mysterious object, silent and vast, hovers above, bathing everything in an eerie red glow. Imagine Norman's fright as he dashes to a nearby house, only to find the occupants too spooked to open the door!The plot thickens when Norman races to the police, and Officers Toland and Bertrand join the scene, only to encounter the baffling sight themselves—a gigantic, dark object with red flashing lights, hovering silently in the night. Despite their bravery (and Officer Bertrand's ready revolver), the trio can't muster the courage to confront the silent visitor. As the mystery deepens, so does the intrigue. It's a classic Scooby-Doo setup, minus the meddling kids and their Great Dane, but with all the chills, thrills, and head-scratching mystery of a real-life UFO encounter. So, grab your Scooby Snacks, and let's dive into the Exeter Incident—where the truth is out there, and it's spookier than you think!Visit us online at itsmysteryinc.comJoin Unmasked at Patreon.com/itsmysteryincAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
44: Mel Waters' Hole: The Bottomless Mystery
Apr 2 2024
44: Mel Waters' Hole: The Bottomless Mystery
In this week's spooky installment of Mystery Inc, we're unveiling a brand new episode format that's sure to have you on the edge of your seat! With two episodes dropping weekly, each featuring a mind-boggling mystery presented by either Shane, Josh, or Kim, along with some thrilling new show features. This episode, Shane takes the lead with a mystery that's as deep as it is perplexing—Mel's Hole.Imagine a seemingly bottomless pit, shrouded in the mysteries of the paranormal, nestled in the remote wilderness of Washington State. Shane, inspired by Mel Waters' eerie call to a paranormal radio show back in '97, delves into the legend of a hole so deep, not even 80,000 feet of line could find its bottom. This hole isn't just a geological anomaly; it's a vortex of unexplained phenomena, from reviving dead dogs to warding off local canines with its ominous presence. And with a twist that seems ripped straight from a Scooby-Doo mystery, the plot thickens with Mel's baffling encounters with military personnel and the hole's inexplicable disappearance from public records.But that's not all, folks! In addition to this spine-chilling tale, Shane introduces a brand-new episode segment inspired by his and Josh's grandma's famous saying, "Shit Fire!" This segment promises to bring even more heat to our mysteries, igniting your curiosity with tales so wild, they're sure to leave you exclaiming, "Shit Fire!" ourselves. So buckle up, Mystery Inc fans, as we dive into the enigmatic depths of Mel's Hole, exploring legends, debunking myths, and perhaps, uncovering a bit more than we bargained for. Don't forget, with our new weekly format, the mystery never ends, and the next clue could be just around the corner. Join us, if you dare, for a journey filled with twists, turns, and tales that even Scooby and the gang would hesitate to tackle.Visit us online at itsmysteryinc.comJoin Unmasked at patreon.com/itsmysteryincAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
43: Veil of Isdal & The Mothman's Tale
Mar 26 2024
43: Veil of Isdal & The Mothman's Tale
In this spine-tingling episode of Mystery Inc, Shane and Josh dive into the enigmatic and eerie tales that have puzzled and fascinated the world for decades. First up, Shane takes us on a shadowy journey to the cold, mysterious woods of Norway, where the story of the Isdal Woman unfolds. Picture this: a foggy morning in November 1970, a hiker stumbles upon a chilling scene – the charred remains of a woman, hidden among the icy rocks, her identity shrouded in mystery. Like a scene straight out of a Scooby-Doo chase, the clues lead us through a maze of fake passports, cryptic codes, and whispers of espionage. But beware, this tale has more twists and turns than a haunted mansion, and the identity of the Isdal Woman remains one of the greatest unsolved mysteries of our time.Then, hold onto your Scooby Snacks, as Josh swoops into the story of the Mothman, a creature as mysterious as it is terrifying, said to haunt the skies of Point Pleasant, West Virginia. With glowing red eyes, large wings, and a penchant for predicting disasters, this cryptid has become the stuff of legends. The Mothman's tale begins in the 1960s, with sightings that send shivers down the spine of anyone brave enough to listen. Through a series of eerie events, strange sightings, and chilling encounters, Josh and Shane, with the help of their trusty Mystery Machine Tesla and Producer Kim, attempt to unravel the truth behind this winged wonder. Is the Mothman a harbinger of doom or merely a misunderstood creature of the night?Join us, if you dare, for a mystery-filled adventure that's sure to keep you guessing until the very end!Visit us online at itsmysteryinc.comJoin us on unmasked at Patreon.com/itsmysteryincAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
41: The Waco Standoff & The Whispering Jinn
Mar 12 2024
41: The Waco Standoff & The Whispering Jinn
In this hair-raising episode we take you on a journey through two bewildering tales that bridge the gap between the corporeal and the supernatural. First up, Shane delves into the depths of the Waco Siege, a standoff that gripped Waco, TX, in a tense embrace. This historic confrontation between the Branch Davidians and federal agents in 1993 spiraled into a 51-day siege that concluded in tragedy and controversy. Shane unpacks the events leading up to the siege, the intense negotiations, and the fiery finale that left an indelible mark on American history. Through a meticulous examination of the facts, Shane aims to shed light on the complexities and the mysteries that still shroud the Waco Siege, making listeners question what truly lies behind the official narratives.Then, shifting gears from the stark realities of human conflict to the enigmatic world of the unseen, Josh explores the ancient and mysterious concept of Jinn, also known as djinn or genies. This segment promises to transport listeners to a realm where folklore, religion, and the supernatural intersect. Josh delves into the origins of Jinn in Middle Eastern mythology and their significance in various cultures, unraveling tales of these shape-shifting beings that are believed to inhabit an invisible world alongside humans. From whispered legends in the sands of Arabia to their representation in modern media, Josh investigates how these entities have influenced human culture and beliefs. Prepare to be enthralled as we uncover the layers of mystery that surround these two fascinating topics, each a mystery in its own right, challenging what we believe to be reality.Visit us online at itsmysteryinc.comAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
40: Whispers in the Wilderness & The Bride of the Desert
Mar 5 2024
40: Whispers in the Wilderness & The Bride of the Desert
Jinkies! In today's thrilling episode, Josh and Shane, bring to light two bone-chilling mysteries that span from the cold, whispering forests of North America to the sun-scorched streets of Mexico.First up, Josh takes us on a harrowing journey into the heart of the wilderness to uncover the ancient legend of the Wendigo. Originating from the folklore of the Algonquian-speaking peoples of North America, the Wendigo is described as a malevolent, cannibalistic spirit that could possess humans and turn them into monstrous creatures driven by an insatiable hunger for human flesh. Josh delves into historical accounts, explores the psychological and environmental factors that may have given rise to such a legend, and recounts eerie stories that claim the Wendigo is more than just a myth.Then, Shane transports us to the bustling streets of Chihuahua, Mexico, where a mannequin in a bridal shop window has captivated the imagination of locals and tourists alike for decades. La Pascualita, as she's affectionately known, is no ordinary mannequin. Rumors swirl about her eerily lifelike appearance, leading many to believe she may be a perfectly preserved corpse. Shane explores the origins of La Pascualita, the legends of love and tragedy that surround her, and the reasons why this enigmatic figure continues to haunt the dreams of those who gaze upon her.If you enjoy diving into the depths of history, unraveling true crime, and exploring mysteries, share this episode with fellow mystery enthusiasts and leave us a review!Until next time, keep questioning the world around you, and remember, the truth is out there, waiting to be discovered.Connect with Us:Website: itsmysteryinc.comEmail: Shane@itsfoulplay.comInstagram: @‌itsmysteryincFacebook Group: Shane & Josh’s Rabbit HoleListener Support: If you love what we do and want to support the show, consider becoming a patron on Patreon. Your support helps us keep the mystery alive.Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
37: Tunes of Temptation & Baba Yaga's Bewitching Tales
Feb 13 2024
37: Tunes of Temptation & Baba Yaga's Bewitching Tales
Jinkies! Buckle up and join Shane and Josh on another adventure, where we dive headfirst into the whimsical and the mysterious. This time around, Shane's taking us on a little trip to the charming town of Hamelin, Germany, to chat about the curious legend of the Pied Piper. It’s a story that’s as baffling as it is fascinating, with its catchy tunes, a town full of mysteries, and a vanishing act that’s been puzzling folks for centuries. As we wander through Hamelin together, Shane will share all the juicy details, from the old tales and historical whispers to the spooky silence that followed the Piper’s tune. So, was the Pied Piper just a figment of our imagination, or is there something more, hidden deep within the legend?Then, it’s Josh’s turn to lead us into the shadowy, mystical world of Slavic folklore with the intriguing tale of Baba Yaga. Imagine venturing deep into the forests of Eastern Europe, where magic is just part of the scenery and Baba Yaga is lurking around, riding her flying mortar and pestle. She’s the legendary witch of Slavic tales, sometimes scary but always fascinating, living in her quirky house on chicken legs. Josh will dig into this spellbinding story, uncovering the mysteries of Baba Yaga and showing us why she’s such a legendary figure in folklore. It’s a tale full of twists, turns, and a dash of magic, perfect for anyone who loves a good mystery with a side of spookiness. So, grab a snack, settle in, and let’s get lost in the mystery together, Mystery Inc style!Listeners, don't miss out on the additional content available at our website Mystery Inc.. For even more exclusive material, including behind-the-scenes insights and special bonus episodes, be sure to check out our Patreon at Mystery Inc | Patreon. Join us on this journey as we explore the unknown and uncover the truth, one episode at a time.Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
36: Mystical Messengers & The Silent World of Helen Keller
Jan 23 2024
36: Mystical Messengers & The Silent World of Helen Keller
Jinkies! Get ready for an adventure into the mystical and the remarkable in this episode of Mystery Inc. First up, Josh delves into the captivating world of Spirit Animals. These mysterious and powerful entities, often found in various cultures and spiritual practices, are believed to guide, protect, and teach us life's profound lessons. Josh will explore the history and significance of spirit animals, uncovering how they're perceived across different cultures and what they symbolize in our modern world. From the majestic wolf to the wise owl, join Josh as he journeys through the spiritual wilderness to discover the secret connections between humans and their animal guides.Then, Shane takes us on an inspiring journey into the life of Helen Keller, a woman who overcame incredible odds to leave an indelible mark on the world. Despite losing her sight and hearing at a young age, Keller's extraordinary journey of learning and communication broke barriers and challenged perceptions. Shane delves into her life story, unraveling the myths and highlighting the triumphs of this incredible figure. It's a tale that proves the human spirit's resilience and the power of determination.Don't let the mystery stop here! Join us at http://itsmysteryinc.com for more enigmatic tales and intriguing investigations. And for an extra dose of mystery and fun, tune into our bonus "Unmasked" episodes available exclusively to our Patreon supporters at http://Patreon.com/itsmysteryinc . It's a chance to get even closer to the mysteries that captivate us and the hosts who love to share them!Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
34: Jameson's Curiosity & Lost Megalithic City of Nan Madol
Jan 9 2024
34: Jameson's Curiosity & Lost Megalithic City of Nan Madol
Jinkies! Shane embarks on unraveling the dark and complex tale of James Jameson, the heir to the whiskey dynasty. Beyond his well-known family name, Jameson harbored a disturbing fascination with the macabre. His alleged involvement in cannibalism during an African expedition in the 1880s remains a topic of intense debate and horror. Shane delves into the heart of this controversy, separating fact from folklore. Was Jameson a mere observer of cultural practices, or did his interests cross into the realm of the unthinkable? This segment promises to shed light on the lesser-known, shadowy side of a famous figure.On the other hand, Josh takes us on an exploratory journey to the mysterious City of Nan Madol. Perched on the edge of the Pacific Ocean in Micronesia, this ancient city is an architectural wonder shrouded in mystery. Composed of massive stone structures scattered across a lagoon, Nan Madol's origins and the techniques used in its construction are as puzzling as they are awe-inspiring. Josh investigates the myths, legends, and scientific studies surrounding this enigmatic city, attempting to unravel the secrets of its forgotten past.For more intriguing stories and unsolved mysteries, visit us at http://itsmysteryinc.com . And if your curiosity isn't satisfied yet, join our Patreon at http://Patreon.com/itsmysteryinc to unlock exclusive bonus episodes in our "Unmasked" series. Dive deeper into the world's most enthralling puzzles with Mystery Inc, where every episode is a journey into the unknown.Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
33: Shambhala's Secrets & The Dark Deeds of Minnie Dean
Jan 1 2024
33: Shambhala's Secrets & The Dark Deeds of Minnie Dean
Jinkies! In this riveting episode of Mystery Inc, titled "Shambhala's Secrets & The Dark Deeds of Minnie Dean," Josh takes us on an enthralling journey to the mythical Shambhala. Hidden in the mists of legend and the peaks of the Himalayas, Shambhala has been a source of fascination and mystery for centuries. Said to be a paradise of wisdom and peace, unreachable by the unworthy, its allure lies in its secrecy and the numerous tales that surround its existence. Josh explores the ancient texts and modern interpretations that continue to fuel the enigma of this lost kingdom. Is it a real place waiting to be discovered, or merely a symbol of spiritual enlightenment? Join us as we trek through history and myth, searching for the truth behind the mystical Shambhala.Then, Shane delves into the dark and disturbing world of Minnie Dean, New Zealand's infamous 'baby farmer.' With a story that's as sinister as it is sad, Minnie Dean's name has become synonymous with one of the most nefarious crimes in the country's history. Convicted of infanticide in the late 19th century, her case sparked sensational headlines and chilling legends. Shane unravels the grim details of her life and crimes, examining the social context of the era and the series of events that led to her becoming the only woman to be executed in New Zealand's history. It's a deep dive into a part of the past that's both shocking and compelling.Don't forget to follow the trail of mysteries with us at http://itsmysteryinc.com , where the intrigue never ends. For those insatiable sleuths hungry for more, join our Patreon at http://Patreon.com/itsmysteryinc and unlock our exclusive series, "Unmasked." Here, we reveal even more spine-tingling tales and hidden histories. The Mystery Inc podcast is your gateway to the unknown and the unexplained – join us, and be part of the gang that dares to dig deeper!Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy